Worst to Best Comic Movies Of All Time

[Alchemist-X]

www.rottentomatoes.com/features/special/2007/comic/

Might be of interest, the rank elektra right near the bottom just above son of the mask, so I figure its on track.

[Nutcase65]

hadn't seen some of these and didn't know some of the others even existed.

I have to put Batman and Robin at the bottom, for my tastes. It was close in their calculations as well.

[Doctor Doom]

I will stick to my guns and say EVERYONE is wrong and X3 is the best comics movie.

[Nutcase65]

X3 was up in the top rankings on the linked site Doom.

[Nutcase65]

39th isn't terrible anyhow. Not top 10 but not with the suckies

[Alchemist-X]

no other comic turned movie franchise did quite what the X-trilogy did. It told truely its own X-story, not just rips from comic stories. The evolution of characters from the first movies to the end is quite the ride i agree.

But removing Nightcrawler from X3 left me wanting just a little more.(The FMV of Nightcrawler in Ultimate Alliance scratched that itch pretty good though)

[thew40]

X3 was a disaster.

[Alchemist-X]

the mishandeling of Psylocke alone makes that a legit opinion.

[iastagehand]

I can't believe they picked Spidey 2 as their #1. In my top 20 but no way #1. I say SIN CITY with the 300 as the best adaptations because they basically are the visual translation of the book to the screen. Sure there are parts in the movie that are not in the book and vice versa but for literal translation they can't be beat. spidey2 sheesh

[balok]

X3 wasn't nearly as good as the first two, but I thought it watchable, light fare. I think that well's gone dry for awhile, though.

I generally agreed with this list, although I haven't by any means seen them all, I can say that those I've seen were about where I felt they belonged.

[spiderwasp]

I too haven't seen a number of these movies but feel the list is not bad based on the ones I have. The only objection I have is that there is no way Hulk should even be as high as it was. It was awful. I also thought that, even though Ghost Rider, Daredevil, and Fantastic Four didn't deserve top 10 or probably even top 20, they were better than where this list put them. Superman IV would probably come in last for me.

[Shiryu]

I would have put the Hulk somewhere in the last 10. It's the only movie ever that made me wish to sell the dvd on ebay (and maybe at some point I will).

[fyrehand]

i disagree alot with the list.
the X-trilogy for me should be not even be ranked. that crap made catwoman with halle berry worth watching. and the first time i saw ccatwoman i vomited mightly.