Post by goldenfist on Sept 26, 2008 15:47:24 GMT -5
Read what Ign.com had to say about Secret Invasion: Spider-Man
I'd like to say SI: ASM #2 falls into the category of the average SI tie-in, showing the lead character fighting a green baddie. Except, as we learned last issue, the lead character is absent. Instead, we're left to worry about the well-being of Spidey's "Brand New Day" supporting cast. Show of hands, would you feel bad if Dexter Bennett got torn limb from limb by a Skrull? Thought not.
The original title of this series was Secret Invasion: Spider-Man - Brand New Day, and while I see why Marvel saw fit to shorten it, that title certainly gave a more accurate indication of what it's about. Essentially, Jackpot finds herself the sole guardian of the new Amazing Spider-Man supporting cast, and once again gets herself into a complicated car chase scene. In an honest moment, I'll admit that I'm one of approximately seven readers who doesn't hate the woman, and I'm mildly intrigued as to her part in the "Brand New Day" tapestry.
The story itself is completely inoffensive, and considering what it is, it does its job. What's worrying, then, is that Marvel seems to think the Spidey Braintrust has done enough work that these characters can support a three-issue limited series on their strength alone. It's plainly not true, as I never once felt engrossed in this issue. If issue #3 were to end with them all roasting in a mass bonfire, I can't imagine myself caring one way or the other. As a result, SI: ASM #2 read as a harmless but utterly hollow experience. It's probably not fair to blame writer Brian Reed because the simple fact is there's no reason these characters should matter to us.
Surprisingly, Marco Santucci's art is the high point of the issue. Every page is clean and traditionally styled, with very few glitches to speak of. A full page dedicated to Jackpot and the DB! cast running down a staircase is immensely effective, not just in storytelling but also in demonstrating Jackpot's powers. The script might be flimsy, but its certainly rendered well.
My feelings for Secret Invasion: Amazing Spider-Man couldn't be classified as outright hatred or revulsion, but I can't honestly recommend it to the casual Spidey fan. "Brand New Day" does have its vocal advocates, however, and I'm sure this sort of tale is right up their alley.
Review Score: 5.9 Mediocre
I'd like to say SI: ASM #2 falls into the category of the average SI tie-in, showing the lead character fighting a green baddie. Except, as we learned last issue, the lead character is absent. Instead, we're left to worry about the well-being of Spidey's "Brand New Day" supporting cast. Show of hands, would you feel bad if Dexter Bennett got torn limb from limb by a Skrull? Thought not.
The original title of this series was Secret Invasion: Spider-Man - Brand New Day, and while I see why Marvel saw fit to shorten it, that title certainly gave a more accurate indication of what it's about. Essentially, Jackpot finds herself the sole guardian of the new Amazing Spider-Man supporting cast, and once again gets herself into a complicated car chase scene. In an honest moment, I'll admit that I'm one of approximately seven readers who doesn't hate the woman, and I'm mildly intrigued as to her part in the "Brand New Day" tapestry.
The story itself is completely inoffensive, and considering what it is, it does its job. What's worrying, then, is that Marvel seems to think the Spidey Braintrust has done enough work that these characters can support a three-issue limited series on their strength alone. It's plainly not true, as I never once felt engrossed in this issue. If issue #3 were to end with them all roasting in a mass bonfire, I can't imagine myself caring one way or the other. As a result, SI: ASM #2 read as a harmless but utterly hollow experience. It's probably not fair to blame writer Brian Reed because the simple fact is there's no reason these characters should matter to us.
Surprisingly, Marco Santucci's art is the high point of the issue. Every page is clean and traditionally styled, with very few glitches to speak of. A full page dedicated to Jackpot and the DB! cast running down a staircase is immensely effective, not just in storytelling but also in demonstrating Jackpot's powers. The script might be flimsy, but its certainly rendered well.
My feelings for Secret Invasion: Amazing Spider-Man couldn't be classified as outright hatred or revulsion, but I can't honestly recommend it to the casual Spidey fan. "Brand New Day" does have its vocal advocates, however, and I'm sure this sort of tale is right up their alley.
Review Score: 5.9 Mediocre